Toxicologic Pathology Forum: Tissue Evaluation in Nonclinical Toxicity Studies for Prophylactic Vaccines.

Nonclinical toxicity testing (GLP) of prophylactic vaccines to support human clinical trials is outlined in the World Health Organization nonclinical vaccine-development guidelines, which are followed by most regulatory agencies globally. Vaccine GLP toxicity studies include at least two groups: a buffer control (often phosphate-buffered saline) group and a highest anticipated clinical dose formulation group. However, studies may include additional groups, including lower-dose formulation groups and adjuvant-containing formulation control groups. World Health Organization guidelines touch upon expectations for dose group and tissue selection for microscopic evaluation, but there is variation in the interpretation of this aspect of these guidelines between vaccine developers. This opinion piece proposes a scientifically based approach for defining appropriate groups to evaluate in the dosing and recovery phases in nonclinical vaccine toxicity studies, as well as suggestions on selecting tissues for microscopic evaluation at the recovery phase of studies to promote alignment between vaccine manufacturers.