Association of ethnic concordance between patients and psychiatrists with the management of suicide attempts in the emergency department.
Psychiatry Research 2023 March 14
BACKGROUND: Suicide attempt is a psychiatric emergency that can be treated with different approaches. Understanding of patient- and physician-related determinants of psychiatric interventions may help to identify sources of bias and improve clinical care.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the demographic predictors of psychiatric intervention in the emergency department (ED) following a suicide attempt.
METHODS: We analyzed all ED visits in Rambam Health Care Campus following suicide attempts carried out by adults between 2017-2022. Two logistic regression models were built to examine whether patient and psychiatrist's demographic variables can predict 1) the clinical decision to provide a continued psychiatric intervention and 2) the setting for the psychiatric intervention (inpatient or outpatient).
RESULTS: In total, 1,325 ED visits were evaluated, corresponding to 1,227 unique patients (mean age; 40.47±18.14 years, 550 men [41.51%]; 997 Jewish [75.25%] and 328 Arabs [24.75%]]), and 30 psychiatrists (9 men [30%]; 21 Jewish [70%] and 9 Arabs [30%]). Demographic variables had a limited predictive power for the decision to intervene (R²=0.0245). Yet, a significant effect of age was observed as intervention rates increased with age. In contrast, the type of intervention was strongly associated with demography (R²=0.289), with a significant interaction between patient and psychiatrist's ethnic identities. Further analysis revealed that Arab psychiatrists preferentially referred Arab patients to outpatient over inpatient treatment.
CONCLUSIONS: The results indicate that while demographic variables, and specifically patient and psychiatrist's ethnicity, do not affect clinical judgement for psychiatric intervention following a suicide attempt, they do play a major role in selecting treatment setting. Further studies are required to better understand the causes underlying this observation and its association with long-term outcomes. Yet, acknowledging the existence of such bias is a first step towards better culturally mindful psychiatric interventions.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the demographic predictors of psychiatric intervention in the emergency department (ED) following a suicide attempt.
METHODS: We analyzed all ED visits in Rambam Health Care Campus following suicide attempts carried out by adults between 2017-2022. Two logistic regression models were built to examine whether patient and psychiatrist's demographic variables can predict 1) the clinical decision to provide a continued psychiatric intervention and 2) the setting for the psychiatric intervention (inpatient or outpatient).
RESULTS: In total, 1,325 ED visits were evaluated, corresponding to 1,227 unique patients (mean age; 40.47±18.14 years, 550 men [41.51%]; 997 Jewish [75.25%] and 328 Arabs [24.75%]]), and 30 psychiatrists (9 men [30%]; 21 Jewish [70%] and 9 Arabs [30%]). Demographic variables had a limited predictive power for the decision to intervene (R²=0.0245). Yet, a significant effect of age was observed as intervention rates increased with age. In contrast, the type of intervention was strongly associated with demography (R²=0.289), with a significant interaction between patient and psychiatrist's ethnic identities. Further analysis revealed that Arab psychiatrists preferentially referred Arab patients to outpatient over inpatient treatment.
CONCLUSIONS: The results indicate that while demographic variables, and specifically patient and psychiatrist's ethnicity, do not affect clinical judgement for psychiatric intervention following a suicide attempt, they do play a major role in selecting treatment setting. Further studies are required to better understand the causes underlying this observation and its association with long-term outcomes. Yet, acknowledging the existence of such bias is a first step towards better culturally mindful psychiatric interventions.
Full text links
Trending Papers
Bacteremia with gram positive bacteria - when and how do I need to look for endocarditis?Clinical Microbiology and Infection 2023 August 32
Abdominal wall closure.British Journal of Surgery 2023 September 16
Antireflux surgery versus antireflux medication and risk of esophageal adenocarcinoma in patients with Barrett's esophagus.Gastroenterology 2023 September 9
Diagnosis and management of prolactin-secreting pituitary adenomas: a Pituitary Society international Consensus Statement.Nature Reviews. Endocrinology 2023 September 6
Get seemless 1-tap access through your institution/university
For the best experience, use the Read mobile app
Read by QxMD is copyright © 2021 QxMD Software Inc. All rights reserved. By using this service, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.
You can now claim free CME credits for this literature searchClaim now
Get seemless 1-tap access through your institution/university
For the best experience, use the Read mobile app