Optimizing Diagnostic and Staging Pathways for Suspected Lung Cancer: A Decision Analysis.

BACKGROUND: The optimal diagnostic and staging strategy for patients with suspected lung cancer is not known.

RESEARCH QUESTION: What diagnostic and staging strategies are most cost-effective for lung cancer?

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: A decision model was developed by using a hypothetical patient with a high probability of lung cancer. Sixteen unique permutations of bronchoscopy with fluoroscopy, radial endobronchial ultrasound, electromagnetic navigation, convex endobronchial ultrasound with or without rapid-onsite evaluation (ROSE), CT-guided biopsy (CTBx), and surgery were evaluated. Outcomes included cost, complications, mortality, time to complete the evaluation, rate of undetected N2-3 disease at surgery, incremental cost-complication ratio, and willingness-to-pay thresholds. Sensitivity analyses were performed on primary outcomes.

RESULTS: For a peripheral lung lesion and radiographic N0 disease, the best bronchoscopy strategy costs $1,694 more than the best CTBx strategy but resulted in fewer complications (risk difference, 14%). The additional cost of bronchoscopy to avoid one complication from a CTBx strategy was $12,037. The cost and cumulative complications of bronchoscopy strategies increased compared with CTBx strategies for small lesions. The cost and cumulative complications of bronchoscopy strategies decreased compared with CTBx strategies when a bronchus sign was present, but bronchoscopy remained more costly overall. For a central lesion and/or radiographic N1-3 disease, convex endobronchial ultrasound with ROSE followed by lung biopsy with incremental cost-effectiveness ratio, if required, was more cost-effective than any CTBx strategy across all outcomes. Strategies with ROSE were always more cost-effective than those without, irrespective of scenario. Trade-offs also exist between different bronchoscopy strategies, and optimal choices depend on the value placed on individual outcomes and willingness-to-pay.

INTERPRETATION: The most cost-effective strategies depend on nodal stage, lesion location, type of peripheral bronchoscopic biopsy, and the use of ROSE. For most clinical scenarios, many strategies can be eliminated, and trade-offs between the remaining competitive strategies can be quantified.