Spectrum of morphological abnormalities and treatment outcomes in ostium secundum type of atrial septal defects: Single center experience in >500 cases.

Background: Transcatheter closure (TCC) has emerged as the first line treatment option for secundum type of atrial septal defects (ASD). Outcomes of TCC depend upon proper delineation of defect anatomy by transesophageal echocardiography (TEE). Stability and proper placement of the device mandates adequate rims and proper alignment to the septum. Failed or unfavorable morphology for TCC requires referral for surgical repair.

Methods: We prospectively analyzed the ASD patients who were referred for treatment. The morphological features of the defect were evaluated and the outcomes of TCC studied. Patients who undergo TCC and surgical repair were followed for immediate and long-term outcome comparison.

Results: Of the 512 patients who underwent treatment, TCC was attempted in 430/512 (83.2%) patients. It was successful in 393/430 (91.3%) patients. The remaining 119 patients underwent surgical patch closure. Twenty patients had failure of device alignment and device embolization occurred in 17 patients. Very large defect size ≥35 mm, absent or deficient posterior rim, absent/deficient inferior naval rim showed high chances for failure and formed major reasons for surgical referral. The surgical group had higher success (100%) across all anatomic variables. However, they had longer intensive care unit (ICU) and hospital stay ( p  < 0.001).

Conclusion: TCC offered a success rate of 91% in complex defects after TEE selection. Very large size and deficient inferior, posterior rims predicted failure of TCC. Surgery offered 100% success and it involved a longer hospital and ICU stay. The long-term clinical results were identical with both treatment modalities.