Analysis of hospitalizations comparing rifaximin versus lactulose in the management of hepatic encephalopathy.

INTRODUCTION: Patients with end-stage liver disease often develop hepatic encephalopathy. The loss in cognitive abilities results in marked economic loss to the patient and health care community. We report hospital admission rates and economic impact of patients with end-stage liver disease suffering from hepatic encephalopathy.

METHODS: The medical records were reviewed involving liver transplant patients started on lactulose or rifaximin therapy after presenting with stage 2 hepatic encephalopathy from January 2004 to November 2005. Information collected included demographics, hospitalizations required for hepatic encephalopathy, economic data, and Model for End-stage Liver Disease (MELD) score.

RESULTS: Thirty-nine patients met study criteria: 24 patients treated with lactulose (group one) and 15 with rifaximin (group two). Group one included 18 men and six women of mean age 48 (range 39 to 58), average MELD 14 (range 10 to 19). Group two included 10 men and five women of mean age 47 (range 42 to 58), average MELD 15 (range 10 to 19). Group one patients required 19 hospitalizations overall: three patients with three hospitalizations, four patients with two hospitalizations, and two patients required one hospitalization. Total drug cost per month was 50 dollars(group one) and 620 dollars(group two). The average annual cost of hospitalization, emergency room visit, and drug per patient treated was 13,284.96 dollars for a total of 318,839 dollars (range 5005 dollars to 26,255 dollars, including drug cost and hospital care). Group two required three hospitalizations, all three with one visit. The average annual cost of hospitalization, emergency room visit, and drug per patient treated was 7958.13 dollars for a total of 119,372 dollars (range 6005 dollars to 19,255 dollars, including drug cost and hospital care). The total cost of therapy per patient per year was 13,285 dollars (group one) versus 7958 dollars (group two). The average length of stay was shorter in group two [3.5 days (range 3 to 4)] versus group 1 [5.0 days (range 3 to 10); P < .0001].

CONCLUSION: These pilot data demonstrate the marked difference in economic costs for the treatment of hepatic encephalopathy. The results also show that in comparative groups, the economic gains are quickly lost when using lactulose.