[Low frequency fluctuating hearing loss without labyrinthine vertigo--a genuine disease? A follow up study after 4 and 10 years].

BACKGROUND: Besides the typical attacks of dizziness, recurrent low-frequency sensory hearing loss--together with mostly low-frequency tinnitus--is also a characteristic sign of Menière's disease. It is therefore often assumed to be a prodromal sign of Menière's disease, even without dizziness.

METHODS: During our longitudinal study, which was started in 1995, we reported that there were 81 patients with recurrent low-frequency hearing loss with no initial vertigo in the first suspense year of 1999. After a further 6 years, we investigated 46 (57%) of these original 81 patients in the second suspense year, 2005, for new components of vertigo, with the questions of development of Menière's disease and further development of the patients' hearing ability and psychic situation in mind.

RESULTS: In all, 12 (26%) of the 81 former patients suffered from vertigo, but only 4 (9%) had developed the typical signs of full-blown Menière's disease with the typical labyrinthine vertigo. Of the 12 patients who suffered from vertigo, 6 (13% of the 81 with vertigo) were diagnosed with psychogenic vertigo, 1 (1%) suffered from benign and treatable paroxysmal positional vertigo and 1 (1%) had developed vertigo after acoustic neurinoma surgery.

CONCLUSIONS: We conclude from our observations that, although almost every patient with Menière's disease suffers from recurrent low-frequency hearing loss, only a few patients with recurrent hearing loss develop Menière's disease. However, many patients with low-frequency sensory hearing loss develop anxiety leading to psychogenic dizziness in fearful expectation of "imminent" Menière's disease. We found that 26% of the patients had persisting bilateral normacusis in the low-frequency ranges, while 34% had unilateral hearing loss that was sufficiently severe to affect their lives and 39%, bilateral hearing loss; however, none of the patients became completely deaf.